Nationwide Pet Insurance Review: Pros, Cons, and What You Should Know in 2025

If you’re a pet owner, you know how important it is to keep your furry friend healthy and happy. But sometimes, unexpected vet bills can add up quickly. That’s where Nationwide Pet Insurance comes in—and it’s one of the top pet insurance providers to consider in 2025. In this Nationwide Pet Insurance review, we’ll break down the pros, cons, and everything you need to know before making your decision.

What Is Nationwide Pet Insurance?

Nationwide Pet Insurance is a well-established provider in the pet insurance industry, offering a wide range of coverage options for dogs, cats, birds, and even exotic pets. They’ve built a strong reputation for providing flexible policies, reliable customer service, and comprehensive coverage that can be tailored to your pet’s specific needs.

Pros of Nationwide Pet Insurance

1. Comprehensive Coverage Options

One of the biggest benefits of Nationwide Pet Insurance is its variety of plans. Whether you’re looking for accident-only coverage, a more comprehensive plan, or something in between, Nationwide offers options that can fit different budgets and coverage needs. Their major medical plan covers a wide range of conditions like injuries, illnesses, surgeries, and hospitalizations, making it a top choice for many pet parents.

2. Exotic Pet Coverage

If you’re a pet parent to an exotic pet, Nationwide stands out as one of the few insurers offering coverage for animals like birds, reptiles, and other non-traditional pets. Most pet insurance companies exclude these types of animals, but Nationwide has specialized plans that cover them, making it a rare option for exotic pet owners.

3. No Waiting Period for Accident Coverage

Many pet insurance providers require you to wait several days or weeks before you can use your insurance for accidents or illnesses. However, Nationwide’s policies typically come with no waiting period for accident-related claims, which is a huge benefit if your pet is prone to sudden injuries.

4. Vet Access

Nationwide works with a vast network of veterinarians, meaning you don’t have to worry about finding a specific vet to get reimbursed. Whether you’re seeing a specialist or visiting an emergency clinic, Nationwide’s wide-reaching network provides flexibility when choosing a vet.

5. Multiple Pet Discount

If you have more than one pet, Nationwide offers a multiple pet discount, which can save you money when insuring more than one furry (or scaly) friend under their coverage.

Cons of Nationwide Pet Insurance

1. Limited Preventive Care Coverage

Although Nationwide’s comprehensive medical plans are robust, their coverage for routine preventive care is limited. Many pet parents seek coverage for vaccinations, dental care, and wellness exams, but Nationwide’s preventive options are often more limited compared to other providers.

2. Higher Premiums for Older Pets

Like most pet insurance providers, Nationwide’s premiums increase as your pet ages. This can result in significantly higher monthly premiums, particularly for older pets or those with pre-existing conditions. It’s important to consider the cost of coverage over time if you have a senior pet.

3. Claims Process Can Be Slow

While Nationwide has a reputation for good customer service, some users report that the claims process can be slower compared to other providers. It may take longer for your reimbursement, which can be inconvenient when you’re trying to manage your pet’s medical costs.

4. High Deductibles for Some Plans

Some of Nationwide’s plans come with high deductibles, meaning you’ll need to pay a larger portion of your pet’s medical expenses before the insurance takes over. This can make certain plans less affordable, especially if you’re working with a limited budget.

What’s Covered Under Nationwide Pet Insurance?

Nationwide offers several types of coverage, including:

Accident and Illness: This is the most comprehensive option, covering everything from surgeries and hospital stays to treatments for illnesses and conditions.
Accident-Only: If you’re only concerned about accidents like broken bones or injury-related expenses, this plan is more affordable but offers limited coverage.
Wellness Plans: Nationwide offers an optional wellness plan for routine care like vaccinations, spaying/neutering, and flea/tick prevention, though coverage is limited.
Exotic Pet Plans: Nationwide is one of the few insurers that offer specialized plans for exotic pets such as birds, reptiles, and other non-traditional animals.

Things to Consider Before Choosing Nationwide Pet Insurance

Before choosing Nationwide Pet Insurance, consider these factors:

Your Pet’s Age and Health: If your pet is young and healthy, Nationwide’s comprehensive plans could be a great fit. However, premiums for older pets can be expensive, and pre-existing conditions typically aren’t covered.
Your Budget: Premiums can vary widely depending on the coverage plan you choose. If you’re on a budget, compare the available options to find the right fit.
Emergency Care: Nationwide’s no waiting period for accident coverage is a big advantage if you want to make sure your pet can get emergency care without delays.

Final Thoughts

Nationwide Pet Insurance provides comprehensive and flexible options for pet owners, particularly those with exotic pets or those looking for robust medical coverage. While premiums can be higher than some competitors, and the claims process may take longer than expected, Nationwide’s coverage options and wide vet network make it a strong choice in the pet insurance space in 2025.

Before deciding on a plan, make sure to evaluate your pet’s needs, age, and your budget. By understanding the details of Nationwide’s offerings, you’ll be able to make an informed choice that keeps your pet protected and healthy for years to come.

Spot Pet Insurance 2025: The Good, the Bad, and the Pawsitive

ASPCA Pet Insurance 2025 Review: Everything You Need to Know Before You Buy